I Remove Collision Insurance – We Get in a Collision

I Removed Collision Insurance - We Get in a Collision #Saving #AutoInsurance #Budget #Accident

This post may contain affiliate links that help Mike keep the posts coming but cost you zero extra. Please see my disclosure page for more details.

File this under the “full disclosure” section of MikedUp Blog… Last week I wrote all about the awesome financial benefits we’d have by removing collision auto insurance from our decade-old vehicles.


“It’ll be great,” I said. “We’ll save hundreds… or thousands if we can stay in these cars for a few more years.” And in my defense, I wasn’t wrong on that point. But there’s that word: ‘if’


Well, it just so happens that one of our vehicles was in a collision… Precisely 3 weeks after I wrote the initial post and subsequently stopped the collision insurance. And as it turns out, there aren’t a ton of savings via lower premiums in 3 weeks. So the benefits of removing collision insurance on that car were about, roughly, close-to… $0.


And zero cents.



Ok, now that those numbers are out of the way – here’s the bad financial news:


That car was totaled and it was immediately time for us to get – A. New. Car!! (imagine Price Is Right style bells and whistles with Bob Barker’s voice – none of this Drew Carey nonsense). More on this in a moment.


If I had it to do over again – I’d still remove the collision coverage


In fact, our remaining decade old vehicle is driving around town without the safety net. I knew the risk when we went into this experiment: if we wreck the cars, the cost of repair (or replacement, in this case) is entirely on us. And because we had done that research up front, and we knew the risks, we had money set aside for the worst case scenario… This scenario?


This is the ultimate point of personal finance:


There will be wins and losses and sometimes you have little to no control of the outcome. But you can know as much information as is possible about your situation and make the most informed decision for YOU. This will be based on both your financial situation and your own personal values.


For us: paying repairs up to $2,500 or financing a new(er) car purchase would not land us in bankruptcy court. So we chose to take the informed risk which yielded a reasonably high probability for success.


Sure, the Division I team should always win out against the Division II schools. But every once in a while there’s an Appalachian State ?. That doesn’t mean you’re betting on them to win outright again next time… (I love this analogy, btw)


Join Over 2,100 Other Team Members!
Learn valuable skills to build wealth, achieve a higher level of fitness, boost your business' profits, and more...  All in support of a healthier YOU!
By signing up you agree to receive regular emails with exclusive content, deals, and more! Unsubscribe at any time - and it is my honor to NOT SPAM your inbox (I promise)


Here’s how we actually “paid” for our gamble


So, here’s where many of my personal finance blogger friends (and actually one of our teammates at work) start to scoff at me and say things like, “You told me never to buy a new car!!” (Which I did actually say to a friend about 9 months ago…)


We ended up buying a new car the day of the accident.



OK. Go get the remote you threw across the room and wipe the coffee off your iPhone screen. I didn’t mean to startle you. But it’s true. We bought a new car… And we financed a significant portion of the car… Yeah…



Here I come back to the whole, “Personal finance is personal,” stump speech.


We’ve been without a car payment for nearly 5 years now, thanks to some generous family (Buick) and good decision making/discipline (Camry). We’ve held off on buying the “hot new car” for 9 years in favor of no payments and low maintenance costs.


Frankly, we’ve earned it. And now that our family is growing (3 yo with another on the way), Dr. Momma Bear needs a safe and spacious car to drive.


So we chose the brand new Subaru Outback for the following reasons (full disclosure, I stole a few of these reasons from Michael Dinich’s awesome post here):


  • It’s one of the safest cars on the road
  • It wasn’t outrageously priced and we plan to drive this car for 10+ years
  • It has solid tech features that help with safety, entertainment for road trips, and comfortability
  • The versatility of space is awesome with folding seats and a huge storage area
  • The Outback has AWD (all wheel drive) so we’re good in the snow and on adventures (and boy do we love adventures)…
  • Some ridiculously high percentage (93%??) of 10-year-old Subarus are still on the road today (built to last)
  • Averages 29 MPG
  • The financing was practically free with 2.9% APR over 72 months – and as we plan to pay it off much sooner than that, the interest cost will be negligible (more on this below)
  • We like the car…


Continuing from #8 above, I can hear you saying now: “Everyone ‘plans’ to pay off the debt sooner but few actually do.”


I hear you and I do agree that many say things they don’t actually do when it comes to debt reduction and personal finance. However, we are the family that is on track to pay off $250,000 in student loans in just about 6 years total, with the original loan period at 10 years.


We know the discipline and steps required to achieve paying off large debts ahead of schedule and we have already implemented a similar plan for our Subaru. And even if we didn’t, we’re talking about $1,000 – $1,500 in total interest over 5 years. As a worst-case scenario, that’s not a terribly ridiculous cost to borrowing $24,000.


So there you have it


I made a sound and informed financial gamble.


I lost the bet.


And guess what – I’m doing it again with our older vehicle… (Please, God, do not let there be another follow-up post to this series anytime soon)


Reader’s Input


Where do you stand on this issue and have you done or considered doing anything similar with your car(s)? Let me know via email or in the comments below – I’m interested to hear where you’re at!



Thanks for reading!


If you’re interested in discovering a better version of yourself – whether with fitness, finance, or family – then subscribe below to MikedUp Blog’s FREE newsletter and let’s improve together!


I’m glad you’re here. Thanks again and talk soon!


– Mike
Join Over 2,100 Other Team Members!
Learn valuable skills to build wealth, achieve a higher level of fitness, boost your business' profits, and more...  All in support of a healthier YOU!
By signing up you agree to receive regular emails with exclusive content, deals, and more! Unsubscribe at any time - and it is my honor to NOT SPAM your inbox (I promise)

You may also like


  1. Ok so, never say never is the lesson here. As long as everyone is safe, it’s just property. Carry on, pay it off & enjoy the journey.

  2. That’s just really bad luck/timing. Sorry. Well it looks like you took it in stride (of course I am not a big fan of financing a new car but to each his own).

    1. Haha! I know – right? This (unnamed) driver had never been in an accident prior to this one. I guess you could say they were due…?

      I agreed with not financing, previously. But at 2.9% it makes sense to put additional toward other, higher interest loans. In a perfect world, we’d pay cash. But currently, our world is imperfect…

  3. Your money your call. But no amount of saying it is so will make me think there is a single brand new car on this rock that isn’t outrageously priced when compared to a 5 or even a 3 year old model of the same car. New cars are a huge luxury that cannot be justified based on their price. But life isn’t about price justifying everything, sometimes luxuries are worth the price because of how they make you feel.

    1. Steveark – Thanks so much for reading and commenting. As of 1-month ago I was 100% with you. NEVER would I ever buy a new car. But it was when I priced the brand new Outback against 3-year-old models and saw the $3,000 price difference $24,500 (new) vs $21,500 (used), the justification I used personally was that the 3 years of use justified the $3k. I completely understand and respect your stance – I was there a few months ago. Sometimes we change our minds. My wife is the one driving the new car and honestly I love all the features listed above – especially the safety factor. Definitely not a luxury car but it is nice to drive. Thanks again for stopping by.

  4. Man that is awful news and bad luck/timing.

    I would still have chosen to do it that way as the odds were far more in your favor.

    Congrats on the new car. I have heard great things about subarus and they do last a long time (hope you have full coverage on it)

    1. The totaled Buick was a 2007, I believe. Plenty of good miles and memories… but, she is no more. Good luck on your gamble and it should also be said that 1 year later – the other car that I took collision insurance off of is doing well (knock on wood).

Let us know your thoughts!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.